NOTICE: This post will no longer be updated. The new Commercial Appeal Compilation is located at its own separate page, accessible by the previous link, or the link in the top bar of this webpage. Please look to that page for future updates concerning the efforts of the Commercial Appeal to violate the privacy of hundreds of thousands of law-abiding citizens here in Tennessee.
On the tenth of February, 2009, I became aware of the fact that the Commercial Appeal, a newspaper in Memphis, Tennessee, had procured a copy of the state’s public database of Handgun Carry Permit Holders, and taken it upon themselves to convert it into a web-based, searchable system, available to anyone with an internet connection. I consider this to be a massive invasion of my privacy, and the privacy of the over-200,000 other permit holders here in Tennessee, in addition to a possible endangerment of those individuals listed in the database. What follows is a documentation of all of the posts, letters, and writings I have penned since, and will hopefully be updated if/when I write more:
10FEB09: A letter to every member of the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal, expressing my displeasure over their publication of the database. No one I sent this email to has ever responded.
11FEB09: Documentation of other webpages expressing their outrage over this privacy invasion.
13FEB09: A reciprocal listing of the contact information for all members of the staff at the Commercial Appeal, as well as whatever other public knowledge is available on them. I would stress that all information on this list is available through public, legal channels, and this information will be deleted from my webpage as soon as the Commercial Appeal takes down its HCP database.
Also on this day, I contacted all of the advertisers I could find on the Commercial Appeal’s webpage, and told them I would never purchase their goods or services again, until either the database comes down, or they stop advertising at the Commercial Appeal.
14FEB09: The Commercial Appeal started writing editorials defending the database and rationalizing their decisions concerning it, and I started fisking those editorials.
15FEB09: It came to light that my commenting account at the Commercial Appeal’s webpage had been banned without cause, explanation, or notification.
Also on this day, the Commercial Appeal continued publishing its rationalizations, and I continued fisking them.
17FEB09: In response to the public hue and cry concerning it, the Commercial Appeal goes and updates their database.
18FEB09: I ask those who are writing to and about the Commercial Appeal to maintain an unquestionable level of decency and courtesy. The editorials at the Commercial Appeal and elsewhere constantly reference “ominous threats”, but without providing any specific examples – we need to keep it that way.
20FEB09: Yet another editorial was published by the Commercial Appeal, and I continued my fisking trend.
22FEB09: I finally heard back from the First Tennesse Bank, one of the advertisers I contacted. I will never use that bank in the future.
23FEB09: And still yet another editorial was published by the Commercial Appeal, and handled by me.
24FEB09: I contacted my local legislators expressing my support of a bill that would make the state’s HCP database private, in addition to other firearm-related bills.
25FEB09: Three of those bills made it out of committee.
27FEB09: Another editorial was published by the Commercial Appeal and addressed by me.
28FEB09: I examine some of the arguments put forward by the supporters of the Commercial Appeal’s actions.
03MAR09: The Commercial Appeal calls in backup in the form of an external writer. Too bad said writer is employed by the same company that also owns the Commercial Appeal…
04MAR09: Even when the Commercial Appeal is just reporting the news, they cannot overcome their bias enough to write an unbigoted article.
05MAR09: Rights advocates in Tennessee make some limited headway, and the staff at the Commercial Appeal simply cannot stand it.
08MAR09: The bigots at the Commercial Appeal let loose with yet another assault on the civil rights of all citizens of Tennessee, with bonus specious rationalizations concerning their privacy-invading database of handgun carry permit holders.
09MAR09: For the sake of compiling all the information in one place, search engine optimization, and general-purpose consolidation, any articles directly relating to the Commercial Appeal have been moved into their own category.
10MAR09: The Commercial Appeal’s invasion of hundreds of thousands of law-abiding citizens’ privacy made it to the Colbert Report. Wierd.
11MAR09: The Commercial Appeal is still associating law-abiding handgun carry permit holders with felons and accidents. No bias there. Nope, none at all.
Also on this day, the Commercial Appeal takes the despicable tactic of conflating law-abiding citizens with the recent murderer in Alabama, while simultaneously still defending their privacy-invading database of handgun carry permit holders.
12MAR09: The Commercial Appeal attempts to make another flawed and desperate-sounding attempt to justify their invasion of over 218,000 law-abiding citizens’ privacy.
Also on this day, Richard Locker, a writer at the Commercial Appeal, says one of the stupidest things I have ever seen.
15MAR09: Otis Sanford, jealous of the attention Richard Locker seems to be getting over his stupid comments, jumps on the hoplophobe bandwagon with his own breed of specious arguments and invective.
18MAR09: Richard Locker almost makes it through a news report without succumbing to his inherent bias. Almost.
19MAR09: Chris Peck has a new way of describing bipartisanship when he does not agree with the outcome: “herd mentality”. The Commercial Appeal’s bigotry knows no bounds.
20MAR09: Richard Locker unfortunately devolves back into being his normal, hoplophobic self.
21MAR09: The Commercial Appeal has to let go of some of their staff, including a cartoonist who drew a remarkably offensive editorial cartoon more than adequately portraying both his and his newspaper’s hoplophobia. More the shame.
30MAR09: The editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal demonstrate that honesty in journalism is dead.
31MAR09: Richard Locker somehow manages to accurately and adequately report the news, and only the news, with a minimum of editorializing and hoplophobia. Wierd.
06APR09: Commercial Appeal columnist Bryan Brasher exposes that he is nothing more than a fuddite, willing to sacrifice other people’s rights so long as his remain safe… for the time. I guess it is good to know who we can count on selling us out.
07APR09: The bill allowing law-abiding handgun carry permit holders to carry their sidearms into restaurants that serve alcohol made it out of the House, and Richard Locker celebrated by writing another strangely bigotry-free article.
08APR09: And then the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal makes up for the previous article by hemorrhaging bigotry all over cyberspace. Someone get them a towel.
16APR09: Despite the countless editorials and “news” articles against them, the bills allowing law-abiding handgun carry permit holders to take their sidearms into restaurants advances.
21APR09: And, likewise, a bill to allow law-abiding handgun carry permit holders to take their sidearms into local parks also advances.
27APR09: The Commercial Appeal pretty much abandons all pretenses and reveals itself for the blantantly anti-rights, anti-self-defense, and anti-Second-Amendment newspaper it is.
29APR09: The Commercial Appeal puts up a poll, the outcome of which they are stridently attempting to ignore.
05MAY09: Chris Peck and the rest of the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal are in denial concerning the amount of assistance they provided HB0959, and how much its passing relied on their incessant hoplophobia and bigotry.
11MAY09: The editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal demonstrates that they just love wielding logical fallacies in addition to their standard hoplophobia, bias, and bigotry.
14MAY09: Ignoring some rather pertinent facts, the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal exposes their agenda of preferring everyone to live lives ruled by fear and emotion rather than choice and the Constitution.
19MAY09: Another poll that the staff of the Commercial Appeal is going to ignore is put up on their webpage.
21MAY09: Chris Peck and the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal indicate that Google is hard. Denial, anyone?
26MAY09: The Commercial Appeal puts up interviews of folks who just happen to agree with the hoplophobic bent of the newspaper. Funny, that.
27MAY09: Richard Locker again manages to report mostly just the news, though he does manage to sneak in a hyperlink to the Commercial Appeal’s privacy-invading database.
03JUN09: Like clockwork, when something positive happens in the pro-rights arena in Tennessee, the Commercial Appeal is there to spread the hoplophobia and copious amounts of hypocrisy.
07JUN09: Wendi C. Thomas, discriminatory bigot extraordinaire, rears her head again at the Commercial Appeal.
08JUN09: It would appear as though Chris Peck and the rest of the staff at the Commercial Appeal are against the concept of private business owners having a choice as to how those businesses are run.
22JUL09: The Commercial Appeal copy-pastes a fallacious Violence Policy Center Google-study verbatim. Yup, no anti-gun, anti-rights, anti-Second-Amendment agenda there…
04AUG09: Unbelievably, the Commercial Appeal received an award for invading the privacy of over 220,000 law-abiding Tennessee residents.
03DEC09: Another newspaper, this time in Indiana, follows in the Commercial Appeal’s footsteps by publishing a privacy-invading database of conceaped carry permit holder information.
04JAN10: Remember, registries of individuals are considered to be punishments, whether the staff of the Commercial Appeal can admit it or not.
Trackposted to The Pink Flamingo, Rosemary’s Thoughts, Leaning Straight Up, third world county, Political Byline, Conservative Cat, and Right Voices, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.
related posts:
moving things around | going to need a database of databases |
calling in backup
I suppose I should be thankful, in some manner, that the most-recent article from the Commercial Appeal concerning their privacy-invading database of handgun carry permit holders is an actual news story, rather than just another editorial. Granted, it …
and the bias meter pegs out
Even when just trying to report the news, the staff at the Commercial Appeal cannot bother to rid themselevs of their anti-Second-Amendment tendencies, or silence their opposition to people being lawfully capable of defending themselves. Bills allowing…
moving forward (slightly)
Once again, the Commercial Appeal tries to report the news, although this time, their obvious anti-Second-Amendment, anti-self-defense, and anti-rights bias is not quite as evident. Bills allowing people licensed to carry guns to take them into state a…
breaking out
For those interested in tracking such things, I went ahead and separated out all of my posts concerning the Commercial Appeal and their privacy-invading database of handgun carry permit holders into its own category, visible on the column to the…
at least they admit it
Mainstream media is moving more and more progressively to the left? And they are just doing it for the popularity, readers, viewers, and page views? Say it ain’t so. I guess attention whores are attention whores, whether they work for…
guess it finally nuked the fridge
I am not entirely sure if this is going to help or hurt the cause of the handgun carry permit holders concerned about the Commercial Appeal’s privacy-invading database: .cc_box a:hover .cc_home{background:url(‘http://www.comedycentral.com/comedycentral…
guilt by association
Do you want to know the best part about the Commercial Appeal’s privacy-invading database of handgun carry permit holders? Here we are, almost a month after this whole froofera hit the public scene, and the staff of the Commercial Appeal…
conflation and association
And, predictably, the Commercial Appeal sinks to a new low, now attempting to conflate law-abiding, private handgun carry permit holders with the murderer in Alabama. Of course, given that the Commercial Appeal was already associating handgun carry per…
trying for more justification
Another day, another rationalization by the Commercial Appeal to defend their privacy-invading database of handgun carry permit holders. Kiandre Sims was well armed the night he kicked in a back door and sexually assaulted his ex-girlfriend. Carrying a…
birds of a feather
It would appear as though Otis L. Sanford was jealous of all of the attention Richard Locker was getting over his idiotic comments earlier, so he has decided to go ahead and jump into the fray with his own variety…
I am very grateful to know people such as yourself who don’t just sit there and whine, but they do something about the horrendous wrongs they see. Great post.
Thanks for the thoughts, Rosemary. I sincerely doubt that anything I am doing here will make an iota of difference to the Commercial Appeal, but I can certainly hope.
must mean a different person
What follows is one of the more amusing claims from one of the hoplophobes supporting the Commercial Appeal’s privacy invasion of law-abiding handgun carry permit holders: The proponent of the “more guns, less crime” thesis, John Lott, has retreated to…
almost there
Surprisingly, today’s gem from Richard Locker, the Commercial Appeal’s leading anti-firearms journalist, was impressively devoid of rampant hoplophobia, pants-shitting hysterics, and other idiocies he has indulged in previously. Mayhap there is hope af…
the same old tune
Just as Richard Locker takes significant strides towards simply reporting the news without bias or agenda, the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal goes and makes up for his progress with yet another bigoted diatribe. Open government advocates were…
regression
Just as we started to have a little hope for Richard Locker, he goes and screws it all up: Nine days after an Alabama handgun-carry licensee shot and killed 10 people — three of them on the streets while driving…
times are tough
I sincerely doubt this has anything to do with the Commercial Appeal pointlessly invading the privacy of over 218,000 law-abiding handgun carry permit holders, but it would seem as though they just laid off 19 employees: The union representing the…
you are doing it right
While writers at the Commercial Appeal are trying to conflate law-abiding citizens with murderers, expose their bigotry at every available opportunity, and be as anti-bipartisanship, anti-firearms, anti-firearm-owners, anti-reality, anti-self-defense, …
honesty is (apparently) overrated
Wow. I have to admit to being somewhat impressed. It would appear as though the Commercial Appeal somehow managed to go over a full week without putting up another hoplophobic, anti-rights editorial. At least it gives me something to write…
in the right direction
It seems as though my natural right to privacy my be reinforced shortly: A proposal to close public access to the database of state-issued permits to carry loaded handguns is headed for vote in the Tennessee Senate. … The panel…
… and a side of hollow-points
Amazingly enough, HB0962 was approved by the Tennessee House of Representatives, and is currently headed to the Senate for their vote. Doubly-amazingly, it made it out of the house with almost no idiotic amendments being attached to it, with the…
sore losers
Just after Richard Locker does a fairly good job reporting on the facts, and just the facts, of the passage of HB0962, the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal decides to go and counterbalance this attempt at honest journalism. Why…
keep on rollin’
As per their standard modus operandi, the Commercial Appeal just cannot keep its pages bare of irrational hoplophobia. The first instance of further bigoty and bias from the staff of the Commercial Appeal does not even merit linking, considering it…
accurate misinformation
In an attempt to capitalize on the publicity surrounding and attention on Tennessee’s Handgun Carry Permit program, News Channel 5 out of Nashville decided to run their own “expose” on the situation. Unfortunately, the opening line of their news report…
fingers in their ears
Maybe the Commercial Appeal should start listening to their readers….
with a side of self-reliance
Once again, the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal exposes the fact that they would prefer everyone’s lives being ruled by fear and emotion rather than logic and the Constitution. However, before I delve into the mess that is their…
watch how you phrase it
The following is a recent comment on a Commercial Appeal news article: I plan on doing the exact same thing just the other way around. I won’t go to a restaurant that doesn’t post a sign. You act as if…
google is hard
The Tennessee Senate recently voted that handgun carry permit holders should be allowed to carry their firearms into state and local parks unless the specific municipalities in charge of those parks say otherwise… and, predictably, Chris Peck and the…
pay no attention to the man behind the curtain
It is always good to see the staff of the Commercial Appeal continue with their rampantly anti-firearm agenda – it makes it so much easier to call them out as being the discriminating bigots they are. Consider this “news” article,…
the inertia just keeps building
Unlike the editorial staff of the Commercial Appeal, who still cannot be bothered to provide links substantiating the claims and assertions in their editorial writings, Richard Locker appears to have figured out the magic of hyperlinks, and was able to…
we need a towel, stat!
Unsurprisingly for those who have been paying attention to Tennessee politics, our governor, Phil Bredesen, decided to veto the bill allowing law-abiding handgun carry permit holders from carrying their firearms into restaurants that serve alcohol. Thi…